Showing posts with label Economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Economics. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Wheat prices reach 22-month high

Wheat prices have hit a 22-month high after a severe drought and ensuing wildfires in Russia devastated crops.

WHEAT FUTURES US CENTS/BUSHEL

Last Updated at 02 Aug 2010, 19:00 GMT Wheat Futures one month chart
price change %
693.25 +0.00 +0.00
More data on this commodity

Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT) wheat for September delivery broke through the $7-a-bushel level in US trade for the first time since September 2008, before falling back to $6.93.

Prices have risen 50% since late June.

Concerns are growing that the rise will lead to an increase in prices of flour-related products such as bread and biscuits.

Gary Sharkey, head of wheat procurement at Premier Foods, which makes Hovis bread, told the Financial Times that the industry would be "unable to ignore a 50% rise in wheat prices".

Analysts are also worried about the possible knock-on effects.

"I think it will have an effect on both food prices and food company profits," Martin Deboo from Investec told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.

Flames are seen in a field at the edge of Voronezh, central  Russia The heatwave and drought have led to wildfires in several regions in Russia

"Experience of 2008's round of inflation would suggest cost side increases from wheat do get passed on to the consumer eventually," he added.

"Generally the wheat content of a loaf of bread is probably about 12-15 pence a loaf [in the UK]. So if this wheat cost increase has to be passed on then we're talking about 5p on a loaf of bread."

He added that the price of other food products could also go up.

"Animals are fed on wheat or wheat derivatives and therefore this will feed through indirectly into meat and poultry prices, so this will have a significant effect on food price inflation generally."

Digging into reserves


Source: US Department of Agriculture

Russia was the world's fourth largest wheat exporter in the 12 months to June behind the US, the EU and Canada, according to the US Department of Agriculture.

Russian Deputy Agriculture Minister Aleksandr Belyayev said that there was no need for Moscow to restrict its grain exports at the moment.

"[Restrictions] will not be imposed yet. The government is to decide, but the situation today does not demand this. It is very easy to reduce exports, but it is very hard to increase it," he said.

Russia has high levels of grain in reserves and will start using those.

But Mr Belyayev said that production levels would be lower than forecast.

"We will manage to produce 70-75 million tonnes, I think," he said.

The Ministry of Agriculture had forecast the grain crop to come in below 85 million tonnes, compared with 97 million tonnes in 2009.

Picking up the slack

Kona Haque, commodities strategist at Macquarie Bank, said that Kazakhstan and Ukraine, who have also been affected by the drought along with Russia, would see their export levels go down, but there would not be a global wheat shortage.

"The crop declines we are seeing [in the former Soviet Union] are very real, 20-25% drops in production leading to equivalent decline in exports," she said.

"But the fact remains that there are still big exportable surpluses in other parts of the world, particularly the US, that will be able to pick up some of the slack."

But she admitted that headlines of droughts and fires meant that it was inevitable that prices would go up in the short term.

"Particularly in south east Asia there are a lot grain purchasers who are scrambling to get hold of as much wheat as possible in case prices rise even further," she said.

http://www.bbc.co.uk

Friday, November 13, 2009

NY trial' for key 9/11 suspects

Alleged 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed will be sent from Guantanamo Bay to New York for trial in a civilian court, reports say.

Citing unnamed government officials, the reports said he would be transferred from the US prison camp in Cuba with four other suspects.

US Attorney General Eric Holder is expected to announce the decision later, the officials say.

Mr Mohammed has admitted planning the 9/11 attacks, the US military says.

The five men have until now been facing prosecution at US military commissions in Guantanamo.

But US President Barack Obama has made closing the detention camp a top priority.

Asked about the reports during a visit to Tokyo, he said that Mr Mohammed would face "most exacting demands of justice".

According to the reports, Mr Holder will also announce that a suspect in the 2000 bombing of the USS Cole in Yemen will be tried at a military tribunal.

Deadline looming

Khalid Sheikh Mohammed has been described by US investigators as "one of history's most infamous terrorists".

They say he has admitted being responsible "from A to Z" for the 9/11 attacks.

Believed to be the number three al-Qaeda leader, he was captured in Pakistan in March 2003.

He told a pre-trial hearing at Guantanamo in December 2008 that he wanted to plead guilty to all charges against him.

The other four men - thought to be the two Yemenis, a Saudi and a Pakistani-born Kuwaiti who have shared hearings with him at Guantanamo Bay - are also accused of helping plan and finance the attacks.


Khalid Sheikh Mohammed pictured upon capture in Pakistan in March 2003  (left) and more recently at Guantanamo Bay (right)
A new photo of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed recently surfaced

The decision to try them in a New York court appears to be part of Mr Obama's efforts to close Guantanamo by 22 January 2010.

His administration says it will try some detainees in US courts and repatriate or resettle others who are not perceived as a threat.

However, questions remain over the fate of those assessed as dangerous but who for legal reasons could not be prosecuted in a US court - prompting suggestions that the deadline will slip.

The BBC

Thursday, November 5, 2009

China 'boosts East Asian growth'

The World Bank has upped its 2009 growth forecast for China from 7.2% to 8.4%, but says the nation needs to encourage more consumer spending.


Chinese factory workers
Manufacturing accounts for about 40% of China's economy

The Washington-based body also raised its projection of 2009 GDP growth in East Asia as a whole to 6.7% from 5.3%, thanks to China's strong growth.

But it said growth in the region could be just 1% if China was excluded.

And it said China, boosted by a recent stimulus plan, must move away from an industry and investment-based economy.

"The economic rebound in East Asia and the Pacific has been surprisingly swift and very welcome, but take China out of the equation and the regional picture is less rosy," the bank said in a report.

"The rebound has yet to become a recovery."

Stimulus package

At the end of 2008, the Chinese government announced a 4 trillion yuan ($586bn; £355bn) stimulus plan involving increased spending on infrastructure to boost the domestic economy.

In China stimulus spending has gone mostly to building roads and other public works projects.

It's a good time to concentrate and focus effort on rebalancing the economy and getting more growth out of the domestic economy
Louis Kuijs, World Bank China economist

Earlier this week, data showed China's manufacturing sector had grown in October at its fastest rate in 18 months.

But the World Bank warned that manufacturing industries would be under pressure next year as the impact of the stimulus faded away.

It also said China could no longer rely on exports and investment to drive growth and had to encourage its own consumers to increase spending.

"We think that now that the government has basically succeeded in dampening the impact of the global crisis, it's a good time to concentrate and focus effort on rebalancing the economy and getting more growth out of the domestic economy," said Louis Kuijs, the bank's chief China economist.

"This calls for more emphasis on consumption and services and less emphasis on investment and industry."

Losing momentum

China's rebound has helped other Asian economies as its consumers and factories buy imports.

But the bank said that growth in the region outside of China would be slower on average this year than in South Asia, the Middle East and North Africa.

Indonesia and Vietnam were doing well but output was shrinking in Cambodia, Malaysia and Thailand and static in Mongolia, the bank said.

And it added that in Singapore and Taiwan industrial production was 15% below the pre-crisis levels of 18 months ago.

http://news.bbc.co.uk

US interest rates left unchanged

The Federal Reserve has kept US interest rates on hold at between 0% and 0.25%, as had been widely expected.


Fed chairman Ben Bernanke
The Fed has kept rates on hold to help the continuing recovery

Despite the US economy growing 3.5% in July to September - its first expansion since June 2008 - rates were left unchanged to further aid the recovery.

The Fed reiterated its view that rates would need to stay at the historic low for an "extended period".

While economic activity had "continued to pick up", it said high unemployment remained a concern.

The most recent official jobless rate totalled 9.8% in September, a 26-year high.

Recovering car sales

Analysts have also cautioned that the economic expansion between July and September was greatly helped by President Obama's $787bn (£480bn) stimulus package, with some fearing that growth will slow markedly when this impetus comes to an end.

Comparison GDP figures

One of the most successful parts of the stimulus spending was the $3bn "cash for clunkers" car scrappage scheme, which gave people who traded in old cars $3,500 towards the cost of a new vehicle.

This initiative operated in July and August, giving US car sales a major boost in both months.

Car sales subsequently fell sharply in September after the scheme had concluded.

However, both General Motors and Ford reported earlier this week that their domestic sales rose again in October, suggesting that the recovery in the US car market has now resumed.

US interest rates were cut to the current level of between 0% and 0.25% in December last year, where they have remained ever since.

Before then rates had fallen steadily from a high of 5.25% in September 2007.

http://news.bbc.co.uk

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

G20 'to call for economy balance'

This week's G20 summit in the US will call for major reforms to promote a more balanced global economy, according to a document seen by the BBC.

A draft paper hints at significant policy changes from G20 countries, including the UK, the US and China.

And while stimulus packages should continue for now, the document called for the creation of "transparent and credible" means to unwind that support.

Leaders will meet in Pittsburgh with the economy high on the agenda.

No enforcement

The document says huge imbalances in the global economy must be ironed out.

If this does not happen, the world will "face anaemic growth" at levels that are "unacceptably low", it says.

However the paper does not suggest any mechanism for enforcing its plans - other than countries coming under pressure from the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

And while no countries are mentioned by name, BBC business correspondent Joe Lynam says the document is suggesting that rich indebted countries, such as Britain and the US, should save more while cautious and savings-oriented nations such as Germany and China increase spending.

The document is ambitious, our business correspondent adds, and is aimed at removing some of the wild economic swings that have marked the opening decade of the 21st Century.

There have long been calls for China to allow its currency, the yuan, to rise, encouraging Chinese consumers to spend more on foreign goods.

But others argue that in the longer term, China should work on improving pensions, healthcare and other policies, to reduce the incentive people have to save so much.

Stimulus withdrawal


A woman shopping in Shaghai
Nations such as China need to spend more, the G20 is set to say

The document appears to back comments made by British Prime Minister Gordon Brown that there will be no early end to the international stimulus package aimed at taking the world out of recession.

But it calls on the IMF and the G20's Financial Stability Board to draw up, by November, "transparent and credible" ways of withdrawing that financial support.

The document also acknowledges that each country will have to find its own way of winding back its support in terms of the scale and timing of the pullback of support.

news.bbc.co.uk

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Gold sales rise despite high prices

Gold prices may be scorching at an all-time high of Rs 16,000, but it has failed to keep away jewellery buyers from making purchases
ahead of the festive and marriage seasons in anticipation that the rates may shoot up further.


"The retail sales as well as the bookings for the wedding season have gone up as people, who were holding back on expectations of fall in prices, started purchasing thinking it might go up further as the season progresses," Mumbai-based P M Shah Jewellers' Dinesh Jain told PTI.

According to Jain, there is great excitement in the market. People have been purchasing the precious metal even during the 'Shradhh', an inauspicious fortnight according to Hindu mythology, which will end tomorrow, he added.

The gold prices today ruled at Rs 15,944 per 10 grams in the domestic markets and in the global market it was at 1,022 dollars an ounce (28.34 grams).

All India Gems and Jewellery Association Chairman Ashok Minawala said, there is a change in mindset of people, who have shown their confidence in gold as an ornament as well as an investment option.
"In the first quarter of this year the jewellery sales have been slow, but since then the demand has picked up and is likely to remain positive till the rest of the financial year," he said.

Echoing his Minawala Surat-based Kushal Das Jewellers' Deepak Choksi said the current positive trend in gold jewellery sales is likely to continue till the end of wedding season, which is till March 2010.

He also pointed out that the current upbeat market mood would help recover some of the losses incurred last year. "We hope to recover last year's loss through robust business this seasons' business and swing into profit," he said.

This year there is lot of new jewellery purchases instead of recycling of old ones, "Which gives us hope that the high prices, which affected last year's sales, is not going to affect sales this season," Minawala said.
economictimes.indiatimes.com

Getting it off your chest

IN A country as fiercely patriotic as Vietnam, you would expect the government to cheer a plan by citizens to distribute T-shirts bearing nationalistic slogans. However, the T-shirts in question carried messages of hostility towards China, Vietnam’s biggest trading partner. Worse, their pedlars were popular and sometimes critical bloggers.

Two well-known bloggers and an online reporter have been detained after the police uncovered an apparent attempt to print T-shirts opposing Chinese investment in a controversial new bauxite-mining project in Vietnam’s Central Highlands and casting doubt on China’s claims to disputed islands in the South China Sea.

The trio, who had all written critically about Vietnam-China relations on the internet, were detained on suspicion of “abusing democratic freedoms” to undermine the state. By the middle of this week Bui Thanh Hieu, a blogger who used the pen name Nguoi Buon Gio (“Wind Trader”), and Pham Doan Trang, a journalist who works for VietnamNet, a news site, had been freed without charge after several days in detention. Nguyen Ngoc Nhu Quynh, who blogged as Me Nam (“Mother Mushroom”), was still in custody.

These are the latest arrests in a continuing crackdown against bloggers and journalists. Ahead of a congress of the ruling Communist Party in 2011, when the country’s top three political posts will be up for grabs, the government is keen to rein in more outspoken commentators. Last December it imposed new restrictions on bloggers, making it illegal for them to publish under a pseudonym or to write about politics. Policing these rules will be hard.

More than 21m people, a quarter of the population, use the internet, according to government figures. Estimates of the number producing blogs range from a low of 1m to as many as 4m. The vast majority are personal diarists, not sociopolitical activists, but the spectacular growth of blogs and the difficulty of regulating them make the government, used to exercising total control of the media, twitchy.

Bloggers who have found themselves in the dock include some who have exposed government corruption or made negative remarks about the former Soviet Union. But the government seems particularly anxious about criticism of China.

Many Vietnamese remain hostile to their northern neighbour, after 1,000 years of imperial domination and a bloody border war in 1979. But the country runs a large trade deficit with China and needs its investment more than ever. This explains the government’s eagerness to push ahead with the Chinese bauxite-mining project, despite widespread criticism from scientists and generals (as well as bloggers). They have questioned Chinese companies’ environmental records and expressed their fears for national security.

International press-freedom groups, which often rank Vietnam alongside China and Myanmar as among the riskiest countries for bloggers, have condemned the latest arrests. Foreign diplomats fear that the clampdown will harm the fight against corruption. The new rules may cow bloggers, and journalists may be too scared to cover anything even vaguely risky—the law is unclear about what they can and cannot report.

But not everyone is deterred. “They only ever go after the big fish,” says one young Hanoi blogger, who has also openly criticised China many times. Besides, he adds, the government may be shooting itself in the foot. When bloggers are arrested, their readership usually takes off.

www.economist.com

Growth in UK retail sales stalls

UK retail sales were unchanged in August compared with the previous month, casting doubt on the strength of the recovery in consumer spending.

Sales growth in July was also revised down, from 0.4% to 0.2%, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) said.

Food sales growth was more than offset by falls in clothing and footwear.

To add to the retail gloom, department store John Lewis announced a fall in profits and predicted tough trading conditions in the coming months.

Big falls

Retail sales rose by 1.3% in June, and analysts had been expecting a third straight month of growth to reinforce hopes that the UK was emerging from recession - as hinted by other data.

There were signs of growth in some sectors. August food sales rose by 0.7%, while non-store retailing - which includes internet, telephone and mail order shopping - and repair shops saw sales grow by 1.1%.

But this was not enough to offset bigger falls in other areas.

All non-food sectors, apart from household goods, suffered declines in sales. The worst hit were textile, clothing and footwear shops, where sales dipped 1.3%.

Department store John Lewis added to the downbeat retail outlook when it announced a 20% fall in profits for the first half of the year, and said it expected the coming months to be tough.

"We expect trading conditions for the remainder of 2009 , and into 2010, to continue to be difficult," said chairman Charlie Mayfield.

He forecast a "slow, drawn-out economic recovery."

Reflecting the growth the overall growth in food sales, however, the group did see stronger performance in its supermarket chain Waitrose.

'Cautious spending'

Earlier this month, figures from the British Retail Consortium (BRC) suggested that like-for-like retail sales - which do not include new stores - fell in August, by 0.1%.

"The official data confirms our own findings that the strong retail sales in June and July were not sustained," said BRC director general Stephen Robertson.


Shoppers on Oxford Street in London
Analysts had been expecting sales to rise

"With unemployment rates at 14-year highs and predicted to increase into next year, most people are still very cautious about spending on expensive items - unless there are sufficient discounts."

Separately, a survey from business group, the CBI, found that orders for UK manufactured goods remained weak.

Of the 555 manufacturers surveyed, 8% said orders were above normal levels, while 56% said they were below normal.

Export orders were particularly low, despite the relative weakness of the pound, the CBI said.

news.bbc.co.uk

Sunday, September 13, 2009

China and US in new trade dispute

China has launched an "anti-dumping and anti-subsidy" probe into imports of some US car products and chicken meat.

The Commerce Ministry said there were concerns the US imports had "dealt a blow to domestic industries".

It comes a day after the US imposed tariffs on Chinese tyre imports in order "to remedy a market disruption caused by a surge in tyre imports".

The case is the latest in a series of recent trade disputes between China and the US.

"In line with national laws and World Trade Organisation rules, the commerce ministry has started an anti-dumping and anti-subsidy examination of some imported US car products and chicken meat," the Chinese authorities said in a statement.

Chinese money
The US has a ccused China of keeping the yuan artificially high

China has called the tyre move by US President Barack Obama "protectionist".

The White House announced duties of an additional 35% on Chinese-made tyres for one year, followed by tariffs of 30% and 25% in the following two years.

While Washington has long accused China of trade protectionism, the US is also unhappy at the high volume of Chinese exports to America, accusing Beijing of deliberately keeping the yuan undervalued to make its exports artificially cheap.

The US trade deficit with China totalled $103bn (£63bn) in the first half of 2009, down 13% from the same period last year.

news.bbc.co.uk

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Crisis 'cost us $10,000 each'

The world's largest economies have spent $10,000 for every person in a bid to fix the financial meltdown of the past year.

New calculations by the BBC, based on IMF data given to G20 finance ministers, shows these countries have spent a total of $10 trillion (£6tn).

The UK and US spent the most, with the UK spending far more, 94% of its GDP compared to 25% in the US. That equates to £30,000 per person in the UK and $10,000 in the US.

Of course, most of this bail-out money was in the form of guarantees to the banking system, and as that system pulls out of the crisis, governments stand to recover most but not all of that money.

However, there are several other ways to measure the severity of the crisis which has led to the world falling into recession for the first time in 60 years.

They all show the extent of the damage and illustrate the point that the damage has been most severe for the rich countries - especially the US and the UK with their large financial sectors - who were at the heart of the crisis.

Private write offs

The private financial sector is estimated to have write-offs amounting to $4tn, of which two-thirds are losses suffered by the big international banks such as Citigroup or RBS.

And although about half of these losses ($1.8tn) are write-offs of securities backed by sub-prime mortgages, the damage caused by the crisis has spread much wider to other banking assets, with big write-offs of commercial mortgages and company loans as well.

These big write-offs, which have wiped out about 10 years of banking sector profits, have also made it hard for the banks to rebuild capital in order to give themselves the security to resume lending.

Many experts think it will take years, if not decades, before lending returns to pre-crisis levels, and reduced lending was one of the key causes of the economic slowdown, along with a massive collapse of confidence in financial markets.

World economy shrinks

The world economy is projected to shrink by 2.3% this year, or nearly $1tn, a loss of output shared by all citizens, but particularly affecting the rising numbers of the unemployed.

If you take into account the fact that the world economy normally grows by more than 2% per year, then the loss of output caused by the recession is almost $2tn - although some of that may be made up in future years.

However, in order to try to boost growth, governments have borrowed billions of dollars in stimulus funds.

Over the next five years, UK government debt is expected to rise from £600bn to £1.4tn, while the US national debt could double to $10tn.

This extra government debt will have to be paid by future taxpayers, whose ability to spend money on government services like health and education will be constrained. The interest on the UK government's debt in 2014 could be bigger than its entire education budget.

Wealth effect

Finally, individuals are also feeling less wealthy as a result of the drop in the value of their assets. Not only are their homes worth less, but their financial assets, such as stocks and shares, have also declined in value in the last 12 months.

The BBC, in conjunction with the Halifax, estimates that in the UK national wealth held by individuals has dropped by £815bn in the past year (comparing end 2007 with end 2008), with a 15% drop in the value of people's homes and a 9% drop in the value of their other financial assets. These figures do subtract the value of debts, such as mortgages, from the overall valuation.

Of course, wealth is distributed very unevenly, and those who are not homeowners and do not have a pension will not be feeling the effects as much - unless they are finding it hard to get a job.

But there is no doubt that it is curbing people's overall spending plans, and thus exacerbating the recession (the so-called "wealth effect").

It may be some time before we return to an era where people were borrowing against the notional value of the increase in the value of their home to buy holidays and big-screen televisions.

And, as these figures make clear, we will all be paying the price of the collapse of Lehman Brothers for some time to come.

The BBC

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Oil price up before Opec meeting


Oil prices have risen ahead of an Opec meeting, as a weaker US dollar made the commodity cheaper in other currencies.

Light sweet crude for October delivery rose $3.10 to $71.12 a barrel as the dollar fell to its lowest level against the euro this year, to $1.4535.

The rise came as oil ministers from the producers' cartel Opec prepared to meet for a summit in Vienna.

Saudi's oil minister said the country would keep supplies steady and did not expect Opec's supply policy to change.

"Saudi Oil Minister Ali Al-Naimi, upon arrival in Vienna yesterday, has described the oil market as stable and current prices satisfactory," the Saudi-owned Al-Hayat newspaper reported.

'Hysteria-driven market'

The meeting is due to begin at 2130 local time (1930 GMT).

An hour after the meeting starts there will be figures out from the American Petroleum Institute showing how much crude oil is stockpiled in the US, with the volumes often having an influence on prices.

Traders will also be keeping an eye on Tropical Storm Fred, which is growing to hurricane force in the eastern Atlantic, but is not currently expected to threaten oil installations.

"This is very much in a dollar-driven, inflation-driven, hysteria-driven market," said Edward Meir, energy analyst at MF Global.

"Opec will likely leave things unchanged and will end the meeting with exhortations to stick to quotas."

5 lessons from the crash

One year ago a perfect storm on Wall Street nearly destroyed your portfolio - and our financial system. Now it's time to take stock.

Even one year later, the speed with which America's financial system unraveled last September still boggles the mind.

The worst financial meltdown since the 1930s began, you'll recall, with a bang. Early in the month the housing crash led to the federal government's takeover of mortgage giants Fannie Mae (FNM, Fortune 500) and Freddie Mac (FRE, Fortune 500) -- whose dividend-paying stocks were a cornerstone of many retirement portfolios.

Within days the crisis had spread to the investment banks. Lehman Brothers soon collapsed under the weight of its bad mortgage-backed bets, while Merrill Lynch was forced into the hands of Bank of America (BAC, Fortune 500).

Then came news that insurance giant AIG (AIG, Fortune 500) faced a credit crunch, leading to an $85 billion government bailout (which turned out to be a first installment). The Bush administration, led by Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson, hastily crafted a Wall Street relief package that was initially rejected by Congress. The Dow plunged nearly 780 points on its way to an eventual 5,000-point rout.

This year the index has climbed about halfway back, thank goodness. But don't allow the recent rebound to make you forget the pain. Even if the worst of the crisis is over, that which didn't kill your nest egg can make you smarter about your investments.

And while your portfolio is still weaker than it was a year ago, the five following lessons from the Crash of '08 will help you strengthen your finances going forward -- and should limit the damage in the next crisis, wherever and whenever it may come.

Lesson 1: Asset allocation still works -- just don't expect a guarantee.

In the wake of the crash, you may have concluded that asset allocation -- the traditional strategy of diversifying among stocks, fixed income, and cash -- is a bust. After all, your U.S. and foreign equities and all sorts of bonds lost money last year.

"The basic principles of asset allocation need to be revised," says MIT finance professor Andrew Lo. He and other experts argue that since market volatility is rising, you must now own other assets -- such as hedge-fund-like investments -- in addition to stocks and bonds to manage risk. And you must be prepared to shift your mix tactically from time to time. "You need to be proactive and adjust as the market changes," he says.

Lo is correct that it's harder to diversify today (we'll get to that in a moment). But the argument that to reach your goals you must rely on new tactics downplays two big lessons of history -- one recent and the other long established.

The first: Many alternative investments such as hedge funds took a beating in the crisis. And in the long run, the evidence is overwhelming that investors who try to time the market generally fail to beat those who don't. As Warren Buffett says, "The stock market has a very efficient way of transferring wealth from the impatient to the patient."

The real problem with asset allocation isn't that it no longer works, but that people expect that it will always work. And that's just not true. The 2000-02 bear showed that even sophisticated asset allocations can't guarantee you won't lose money in a lousy market. "That doesn't mean asset allocation is a bad idea," says Harvard economics professor John Campbell. "If vaccines don't work for swine flu, it doesn't mean you shouldn't vaccinate for other types of flu."

And if you look at the numbers, you'll see that proper diversification did you considerable good in this meltdown. Yes, most stocks and many fixed-income categories rang up huge losses. But long-term U.S. Treasuries gained more than 27% last year (see the chart at right). High-quality U.S. corporate and global bonds also made money -- as did cash.

If you held a mix of 35% U.S. stocks, 25% foreign stocks, 10% cash, and 30% fixed income (including government and high-quality corporate bonds), you would have lost just 28% between Sept. 1, 2008, and the market's bottom of March 9. By comparison, the S&P 500 was down nearly 50%.

Lesson 2: The world is riskier -- and will stay that way.

Remember the Great Moderation? The phrase describes the recent quarter-century period when economic growth looked limitless and the long-term risk in stocks seemed to be disappearing. Between 2003 and 2007, for example, the Chicago Board Options Exchange Volatility Index (VIX) (VIX) -- a well-known gauge of how risky investors think the market is -- hovered in the 1015 range. That was down considerably from the index's historical average of about 20.

Risk, of course, returned with a vengeance. Last October, at the height of the banking crisis, the VIX hit an all-time high of 80. At those levels, a conservative portfolio that held 30% in stocks and 70% in bonds would bounce up and down the way a 60% stock/40% bond portfolio did before the market meltdown.

Today the VIX has fallen back to around 25. The question is, should you brace yourself for more nerve-jangling spikes? Yes, according to many investment pros, including Yale finance professor Roger Ibbotson, founder of Ibbotson Associates.

He expects the market to remain jittery for several years. Blame the unstable economy, which is likely to deliver more corporate earnings disappointments, and shell-shocked investors who are likely to react sharply to any bad news. "Given the higher volatility today," says Ibbotson, "you may need to ratchet down the risk in your portfolio."

That doesn't mean you should reverse your 60% stock/40% bond portfolio, or that you should do something even more radical. Instead, revisit your investment mix to make sure you're taking on an appropriate amount of risk in light of your financial goals and your tolerance for more market shocks.

Studies show that most of us, not surprisingly, think we can handle more risk when the market is rising than when it's falling. That makes last year's plunge an ideal stress test, says Michael Schlachter, managing director at Wilshire Associates. So ask yourself, How well did I handle it? If you were gulping down Xanax, cut back your stocks by five or 10 percentage points while boosting your fixed-income allocation.

By easing back on equities to accommodate a slightly greater weighting in bonds and cash, you sacrifice some potential return. But not as much as you might think.

Over the past 30 years, a 70% stock/30% bond portfolio gained just two-tenths of a point less a year than an 80%/20% mix. Yet it would have lost less in the downturn. And if smaller losses keep you from undoing your long-term plans in a crisis, that may be well worth the cost.

Lesson 3: Real diversification is harder to achieve than it looks.

As AIG, Lehman, and other financial giants teetered on the edge last fall, you learned to your unpleasant surprise that Wall Street's woes were dragging down your Main Street portfolio.

Say you were the conservative type who likes funds focusing on low-priced stocks that pay dividends. Well, the typical large-stock "value" fund held more than 30% of its assets in financials before the crisis. Even S&P 500 index funds had as much as a 20% stake in banks, brokerages, and insurers (about twice the current level), since they had grown into a huge part of the market in the credit boom.

As for that bond fund delivering above-average yields, it likely held an above-average helping of subprime mortgage bonds. "People were loading up on the most speculative assets but didn't realize it," says Ibbotson chief economist Michele Gambera.

The best way to avoid too much exposure to any industry or asset -- especially frothy ones -- is to drill down in your portfolio to see what you actually own. Use the Instant X-ray tool at Morningstar.com, which will show how much your funds' holdings overlap and whether your portfolio tilts heavily toward one industry or style.

Another idea: Stick to index funds. As noted, an S&P 500 or total stock market fund can't keep you from getting caught up in the market's momentum. But it's always clear what index funds own, because they mirror well-known benchmarks for which information is readily available.

And you can use a combination of index funds to tack against the tide. Say technology stocks, which are zooming now, start to account for a huge portion of the S&P's market capitalization as they did in 19982000. You could shift some of your holdings to an S&P 500 value index fund, which holds less than 8% of its assets in tech.

Of course, owning different stock funds -- be they actively or passively managed -- won't adequately diversify you, since most equities are positively correlated. Translation: They tend to move in the same direction. And correlations among assets have been growing, as global markets are now intertwined.

That's why you must own high-quality bonds -- especially safe U.S. Treasuries and inflation-protected TIPS bonds, says Gambera. They're often negatively correlated with stocks, so they zig when stocks zag. And you should own foreign bonds to diversify your domestic ones.

Lesson 4: Recognizing a bubble is hard. Hedging against one is harder.

"To spot a bubble in advance requires a judgment that hundreds of thousands of informed investors have it all wrong," said then-Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan in 1999. He should know how hard that is: He failed to detect two of history's frothiest markets -- in tech stocks and in housing.

Then again, how many of us paid attention when Yale economist Robert Shiller -- who correctly called the Internet bubble -- started warning that homes were wildly overvalued?

Given how hard it is to shield yourself from the fallout of a bubble, you may be tempted to try alternative investments, such as long-short funds, which attempt to hedge against the market.

One type, absolute-return funds, aims for positive results in any environment. So-called market-neutral funds seek to beat Treasury bills while remaining uncorrelated with stocks. But in 2008 the typical long-short fund fell 15%, while some lost nearly 40%. When bubbles burst, you can run but you can't totally hide.

The one sure hedge: a healthy dose of cash, an asset all but forgotten during the boom. Don't ignore it now.

Lesson 5: You can't time the market, but you can time yourself.

While you can always find a few savvy folks who have managed to outguess the market, Buffett points out that the vast majority of us fail miserably at market timing.

That said, you should always be timing your own circumstances. Every year that passes is another year you get closer to retirement. Over time this will require you to dial back the percentage of your nest egg that you hold in equities. Yet heading into 2007, nearly 40% of workers ages 56 to 65 held 80% or more of their 401(k)s in stocks. A less stock-heavy portfolio would have been far more appropriate -- and safer.

Then there are circumstances specific to you and your family. Sure, your allocation may have been right when you last rebalanced your portfolio. But what if your employer has run into financial problems recently and you fear losing your job? What if your spouse is coping with a medical emergency, or you're now financially responsible for an aging parent?

If you're dealing with these kinds of situations, it's more important to preserve your principal and build up some additional cash reserves than to earn the highest possible returns. In that case there's nothing wrong with shifting some of your equities into safer, more liquid investments.

This is not a repudiation of asset allocation, but a recognition that your life has changed. And it's that kind of timing that will guide your portfolio safely through good times and bad.
By Penelope Wang, Money magazine senior writer

Monday, September 7, 2009

Trichet Says World Economy Shows Signs of Stabilizing (Update1)

European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet, who chaired a meeting of central bankers today, said the global economy is showing signs of emerging from its worst recession in more than 60 years.

Latest indicators have been better than anticipated and stabilization is “something which seems to be confirmed at the global level,” Trichet said at a press conference at the Bank for International Settlements in Basel, Switzerland. “It’s not excluded that we would have a bumpy road ahead and of course alertness remains of the essence,” he said.

Central bankers have cut borrowing costs to record lows and injected billions into the financial system after the U.S. housing slump triggered the collapse of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc a year ago, throwing the global economy into its worst slump since the Great Depression. Governments are also trying to kick- start growth with stimulus packages.

The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development said on Sept. 3 that the combined economy of the Group of Seven nations will shrink 3.7 percent this year, less than the 4.1 percent contraction it projected in June. The U.S., Japan, Germany and France will all show growth in the current quarter while Canada and the U.K. will continue to shrink, the Paris- based group forecast.

Free Fall Over

“A number of projections had been slightly revised up, confirming that we’re probably, in a large part of the economy, out of the period of free fall,” Trichet said. Still, “we have to remain prudent and cautious.”

Trichet met in Basel with his counterparts from the world’s largest central banks including Bank of Japan Governor Masaaki Shirakawa and China’s central bank governor, Zhou Xiaochuan.

While some policy makers have stressed the need to withdraw emergency measures as soon as the economy improves in order to prevent inflation, the Federal Reserve, the Bank of England, the Bank of Japan and ECB are still in the process of implementing asset-purchase programs in a bid to encourage lending. The ECB on Sept. 3 kept its key rate at a record low of 1 percent after loaning banks as much money as they wanted for 12 months and starting to purchase covered bonds.

Trichet said there’s “a great unity of purpose” among central bankers to deliver price stability. “This unity of purpose doesn’t mean that we do the same because we’re in different situations,” he said.

‘Lessons’

Central banks and governments around the world are seeking tougher regulation after excessive risk-taking by financial institutions sparked $1.61 trillion in losses and writedowns and led to taxpayer-funded bailouts.

The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision yesterday agreed lenders should raise the quality of their capital by including more stock. Financial firms will also have to introduce a leverage ratio and devise ways to boost reserves when the economy is robust, the panel said.

Central banks and governments must “draw all the lessons from the past” in order to ensure that new bubbles aren’t created and “abnormal” risk-taking doesn’t re-emerge, Trichet said.

The Global Economy Meeting is held every two months under the auspices of the BIS, the central bank of the world’s central banks.

By Simone Meier and Christian Vits

MrsCentral banks back new regulation

Central bankers have backed new measures to strengthen supervision of the global banking industry.


ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet
ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet presided over the Basel meeting

A meeting of the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), which consists of the world's central banks, pledged to increase bank's capital requirements.

The plans should "substantially reduce the probability and severity of economic and financial stress," the BIS said.

But the BIS did not set out a timeline for implementation of the proposals.

The measures will be outlined in detail by year-end and be introduced in a way "that does not impede the recovery of the real economy".

The BIS meeting comes just after the finance ministers from the Group of 20 richest nations meeting in London backed a system that rewards long-term performance rather than short-term risk-taking.

But they could not agree on specific limits on the amounts individual bankers get paid.

Tier one

The BIS, established in 1930 in the aftermath of the Great Depression, consists of 55 member central banks and is based in Basel.

The meeting, on Sunday, was held by members of the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision.

"The agreements reached today among 27 major countries of the world are essential as they set the new standards for banking regulation and supervision at the global level," said Jean-Claude Trichet, the head of the European Central Bank chief who presided the meeting.

In addition to holding on to more capital, the BIS agreed to boost the standards for so-called "tier one" capital requirements - which essentially means the quality of the assets that banks have on their books in relation to their deposits.

Basel Committee head Nout Wellink, also the president of the Dutch central bank, also said that banker compensation should be "properly aligned with long-term performance and prudent risk-taking."

BBC

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

When Medicare Was Defeated (Again and Again)

Anyone interested in the history of health reform may enjoy this essay by Larry DeWitt, public historian at the Social Security Administration. It’s one of the sources for my column in Wednesday’s paper.

In the column, I focused on the origins of Medicare as a incremental measure, after Harry Truman’s plans for universal coverage failed. But among other good details, the essay also includes a 1960s cameo by Ronald Reagan:

The [American Medical Association's] campaign against Medicare also marked the beginning of the political career of another rising force in American politics — Ronald Reagan. Most conventional histories of Reagan’s political career date his emergence as a political figure from his nominating speech on behalf of Barry Goldwater at the 1964 Republican Convention. But in 1963 Reagan was the AMA’s spokesman for their campaign against Medicare. The AMA, in what was called Operation Coffee Cup, organized thousands of small meetings in homes all across the land, hosted by the wives of AMA physicians. At these informal “coffees” the women would organize local efforts against the pending Medicare legislation. This would include letter-writing campaigns to members of Congress, petition drives, networking with other civic groups, and the like. The central event of each meeting was the playing of a recording made of Reagan presenting a short, dramatic, speech against the evils of Medicare. Reagan played the socialized medicine theme to the hilt, suggesting that the idea of government sponsored medical insurance was little short of the entering wedge of socialist domination of America. His concluding appeal is typical of his sales pitch:

“… behind it will come other Federal programs that will invade every area of freedom as we have known it in this country. Until one day, as Norman Thomas said, we will awake to find that we have socialism. And if you don’t do this and if I don’t do it, one of these days you and I are going to spend our sunset years telling our children and our children’s children what it once was like in America when men were free.”
economix.blogs.nytimes.com

Australian growth beats forecasts

news.bbc.co.uk

The Australian economy grew by more than expected in the second quarter of 2009, boosted by increases in household consumption and business investment.

The economy expanded by 0.6% in the three months to June from the previous quarter, the government said.

Analysts had forecast growth of 0.2% after a sharp drop in export prices was announced earlier in the week.

The government has announced stimulus measures of 42bn Australian dollars ($35bn; £21bn) in the past year.

Australia is one of the few developed countries to have avoided falling into a recession.

Adam Carr, chief economist at ICAP, called the results "fantastic".

"It's looking like we will be firing on all cylinders in H2 [the second half of the year] and 2010," he said.

He added that he thought the Reserve Bank would raise interest rates before the end of the the year.

On Tuesday, figures showed Australian export prices in the second quarter had fallen by 15.8% - the largest drop in the 50 years since records began.

news.bbc.co.uk

Monday, August 31, 2009

Yen overshadows election optimism

economics
Japanese shares fell on Monday after rises to the yen and big stock falls in China overshadowed earlier optimism at the general election result.

The victory of Yukio Hatoyama's Democratic Party of Japan had earlier seen the country's main share index, the Nikkei, hit an 11-month high.

However, the yen's rise and Chinese share declines saw the Nikkei end the day's trading down 0.4% to 10,493.

Shanghai stocks ended down 6.2% on fresh fears that shares are overvalued.

The fall dragged down Hong Kong's Hang Seng index, which lost 1.9%.

'Bad impact'

Against the greenback, the yen was up 1% to a seven-week high of 92.54 yen per dollar.

Analysts said the yen was being bought as a haven purchase following the share declines in Shanghai.


This in turn dragged down the stocks of Japan's main exporters, such as Honda, as a higher yen eats into their overseas earnings.

"The election probably had an impact for about the first 30 minutes of trade, when stocks jumped, but then the stronger yen and Shanghai pushed the market lower," said Koichi Ogawa, chief portfolio manager at Daiwa SB Investments.

"Exporters, such as carmakers and tech firms, are very sensitive to the higher yen and even though the market's pretty surely bottomed out, this could still have a bad impact."

The victory of the Democratic Party of Japan ends 54 years of almost unbroken rule by the Liberal Democratic Party.
bbc.co.uk

Price falls slowing in eurozone

economics
The eurozone's annual rate of inflation was negative in August for the third consecutive month.

Prices in the 16-nation bloc fell 0.2% in the past year, Eurostat said, following the record 0.7% fall in July.

Inflation in the eurozone has been dragged down by lower energy and food prices and by falling demand from both companies and households.

The downward trend began in June with a 0.1% fall in prices, but a Japan-style deflationary spiral is not predicted.

Oil effect

Deflation is considered damaging to an economy because consumers tend to delay making major purchases until prices fall further. Without consumer spending to stimulate growth, economic output falls.

The European Central Bank's target rate for inflation is just below 2%.

The reduced rate of price falls in August is "clearly primarily due to oil prices falling at a significantly reduced rate year-on-year," said Howard Archer, chief European economist at IHS Global Insight.

"It seems highly probable that July marked the deepest deflation in the eurozone and consumer prices will turn positive year-on-year within the next couple of months," he added.

Inflation in the eurozone peaked at 4.1% in July last year, when oil reached a record high of $147 a barrel.

The price of oil has since fallen back to about $70 a barrel.
newsvote.bbc.co.uk

Saturday, August 29, 2009

The Failure of the Economy & the Economists

By now there are few people who do not acknowledge that the major American financial institutions and the markets they dominate turn out to have served the country badly in recent years. The surface evidence of this failure is the enormous losses—more than $4 trillion on the latest estimate from the International Monetary Fund—that banks and other lenders have suffered on their mortgage-related investments, together with the consequent need for the taxpayers to put up still larger sums in direct subsidies and guarantees to keep these firms from failing. With nearly 9 percent of the labor force now unemployed and still more joining their ranks, industrial production off by 13 percent compared to a year ago, and most companies' profits either falling rapidly or morphing into losses, it is also evident that the financial failure has imposed huge economic costs.

The government has moved aggressively, and on several fronts, to stanch the immediate damage. The Federal Reserve has not only eased monetary policy to the point of near-zero short-term interest rates but created a profusion of new programs to extend credit to banks as well as other lenders. Congress, at the Obama administration's behest, has enacted nearly $800 billion of new spending and tax cuts aimed at stimulating business and consumer spending. First the Bush administration and now Mr. Obama's have experimented with one new plan after another to rescue lenders and reliquify collapsed credit markets.
NYRB Summer Sale!

But despite the universal agreement that no one wants any more such failures once this one has passed, there is a troubling lack of attention to reforms that might prevent such a crisis from recurring. By now everyone realizes that excessive risk-taking, systematic mispricing of assets, and, often, plain reckless behavior (not to mention some instances of criminality, although to date surprisingly few of these have come to light) helped cause the current mess. At the same time, most people recognize both that parts of the American economy have been capable of dynamic growth and that the US financial markets have had a part in promoting that growth. The result is a reluctance to consider changes to the current system. Substantial interference with financial markets, it is said, amounts in the end to centrally planned allocation of an economy's investment process, and will result in technological stagnation and wasted resources. Milder attempts at regulation will either prove ineffective—the private sector can afford better lawyers than the government can—or at best merely lead financial institutions to relocate to more lightly regulated jurisdictions like the Cayman Islands.

As in past financial declines, what is sorely missing in this discussion is attention to what function the financial system is supposed to perform in the economy and how well it has been doing it. Today attention is mostly focused on banks' and other investors' losses from buying mortgage-backed securities at inflated prices. What is neglected is the consequence: if the prices of the securities were too high, this meant that the underlying mortgage rates were too low, and so too many houses were built, and too many Americans bought them. In just the same way, when the 1990s stock market boom crashed, everyone talked about investors' losses on their telecom stocks, not the fact that if the stocks' prices were too high, the cost of capital to the firms that issued the stocks was too low, and so communications companies laid millions of miles of fiber-optic cable that nobody ended up using.

In both instances, the cost was not just financial losses but wasted real resources. True, over longer periods of time the American financial system has seemed reasonably effective at allocating resources rather than wasting them. The economy's pace of technological advance and growth in production since World War II suggest that the banks and the stock and bond markets can steer investment capital reasonably effectively to firms that will use it productively, often including start-ups trying out a wholly new idea—Microsoft, or Google, or, earlier on, Apple. But the effectiveness of the economy's mechanism for allocating capital should be a matter for serious quantitative evaluation, not a matter of faith.

Moreover, to ask just how efficient a financial system is in allocating capital leads naturally to the question of the price that is paid for such efficiency. In recent years the financial industry has accounted for an unusually large share of all profits earned in the US economy. The share of the "finance" sector in total corporate profits rose from 10 percent on average from the 1950s through the 1980s, to 22 percent in the 1990s, and an astonishing 34 percent in the first half of this decade.[1]

Those profits accruing to the financial sector are part of what the economy pays for the mechanism that allocates its investment capital (as well as providing other services, like checking accounts and savings deposits). But even a stripped-down version of the cost of running the financial system includes not just the profits that financial firms earn but also the salaries, the office rents, the travel budgets, the advertising fees, and all of the other expenses they pay. The finance industry's share of US wages and salaries has likewise been rising, from 3 percent in the early 1950s to 7 percent in the current decade.[2] An important question—which no one seems interested in addressing—is what fraction of the economy's total returns to productively invested capital is absorbed up front by the financial industry as the costs of allocating that capital.

Further, the latest financial crisis is a sharp reminder that the simple operating expense of running the financial system—including profits of financial firms—is not the only cost if this system also exposes the economy at large to episodic losses in production and incomes, and to the need for taxpayer subsidies. Today those losses are mounting, and so are the subsidies. Many US banks, including some of the largest ones, are now insolvent. The bank rescue plans offered to date by both the Bush and the Obama administrations amount to ever more expensive fig leafs for avoiding concrete recognition of this sad development.

In the same effort, the Financial Accounting Standards Board—the independent organization designated by the SEC to set accounting standards—acting at the strong urging of Congress, recently changed its rules to allow banks more latitude to claim that assets on their balance sheets are worth more than what anyone is willing to pay for them. (Next time you apply for a loan, try mentioning FAS 157-4 and telling your banker that you should be allowed to calculate your net worth with your house priced not at what comparable houses are selling for now but at what you paid for it and what you hope you'll get for it if you hold on to it for some years. The banker will laugh, even while the bank applies just such standards to its own balance sheet.)

Another fundamental issue that the current discussion has overlooked almost entirely is the distinction between the losses to banks and other lenders that reflect genuine losses of wealth to the economy, and other losses that don't. When the value of your house falls, that's a loss of wealth to the economy as a whole. If you keep paying your mortgage, you bear the loss yourself: your net worth is diminished by the amount of the decline in the home's price. If you default on your loan, then someone else—maybe the bank that lent you the money, maybe some investor to whom the bank sold the loan—also bears part of the loss. If the government steps in and reimburses the bank, or the investor, the taxpayers will bear part of the loss as well. But however this loss is divided, what is inescapable is that someone, somewhere, will bear it. What much of today's debate is about is how these losses should be divided among homeowners, banks, loan-purchasing investors, and the taxpayers. But the loss must be borne by someone, and America's economy is poorer because it has occurred.

By contrast, suppose you and your neighbor have bet on whether today's peak temperature would exceed fifty degrees. One of you was right, the other wrong. One of you won, the other lost, and the amount the winner won is identical to what the loser lost. There is no loss of wealth to the economy, merely a transfer of wealth from the loser to the winner. Many of the huge losses that American financial institutions have sustained in the current crisis are of this second kind. None of them was betting on the weather, but they were taking positions that amounted to placing bets on outcomes that represented no change in wealth to the economy as a whole. And with regard to these positions, for every loser featured in the latest newspaper story about banks posting losses and turning to the government for bailouts there is also, somewhere, a winner.

The most telling example, and the most important in accounting for today's financial crisis, is the market for credit default swaps. A CDS is, in effect, a bet on whether a specific company will default on its debt. This may sound like a form of insurance that also helps spread actual losses of wealth. If a business goes bankrupt, the loss of what used to be its value as a going concern is borne not just by its stockholders but by its creditors too. If some of those creditors have bought a CDS to protect themselves, the covered portion of their loss is borne by whoever issued the swap.

But what makes credit default swaps like betting on the temperature is that, in the case of many if not most of these contracts, the volume of swaps outstanding far exceeds the amount of debt the specified company owes. Most of these swaps therefore have nothing to do with allocating genuine losses of wealth. Instead, they are creating additional losses for whoever bet incorrectly, exactly matched by gains for the corresponding winners. And, ironically, if those firms that bet incorrectly fail to pay what they owe—as would have happened if the government had not bailed out the insurance company AIG—the consequences might impose billions of dollars' worth of economic costs that would not have occurred otherwise.

This fundamental distinction, between sharing in losses to the economy and simply being on the losing side of a bet, should surely matter for today's immediate question of which insolvent institutions to rescue and which to let fail. The same distinction also has implications for how to reform the regulation of our financial markets once the current crisis is past. For example, there is a clear case for barring institutions that might be eligible for government bailouts—including not just banks but insurance companies like AIG—from making such bets in the future. It is hard to see why they should be able to count on taxpayers' money if they have bet the wrong way. But here as well, no one seems to be paying attention.

Why has there been so little discussion of fundamental issues like this distinction among losses? Why is so little said about the trade-off between the goal of allocating the economy's capital efficiently and the need to shrink the enormous costs of the financial industry in doing so? One obvious reason is political. There is a long arc from Roosevelt's acceptance of a useful role for government institutions and government regulation to the conviction of Reagan and Thatcher that the government is never the solution but actually the problem. A second, closely related reason is ideological: the faith, personified by Alan Greenspan with his early dedication to the writings of Ayn Rand and his staunch opposition to regulations while chairman of the Federal Reserve, that private, profit-driven economic activity is self-regulating and, when necessary, self-correcting.

The economists George Akerlof and Robert Shiller suggest a third reason. In their view, the problem is also intellectual—a systematic failure of thinking on the part of their fellow economists. Taking the title of their new book from a phrase famously used by John Maynard Keynes, Akerlof and Shiller argue that what is missing in the worldview of today's economists is sufficient attention to "animal spirits," by which they mean the psychological and even irrational elements that figure importantly in so many other familiar aspects of personal choices and personal behavior, and that, they believe, pervade economic behavior too.

Akerlof and Shiller identify five distinct elements in what they call "animal spirits": confidence, or the lack of it; concern for fairness, that is, for how people think they and others should behave—for example, that a hardware store shouldn't raise the price of snow shovels after a blizzard despite the increased demand; corruption and other tendencies toward antisocial behavior; "money illusion," meaning susceptibility to being misled by purely nominal price movements that, because of inflation or deflation, do not correspond to real values; and reliance on "stories"—for example, inspirational accounts of how the Internet led to a "new era" of productivity. The omission of these five aspects of "animal spirits," they argue, blocks conventional economics from either understanding today's crisis or providing useful ideas for dealing with it.

Most of Animal Spirits consists of surveys of disparate research programs in which either Akerlof or Shiller or both have participated—in many cases, led the way—demonstrating that the conventional economic models fail to fit the facts of one or another aspect of observable economic behavior. The topics they cover include (among others) joblessness, saving, the volatile prices of financial assets and of real estate, and the prevalence of poverty among African-Americans. Akerlof, a professor at Berkeley who deservedly won the Nobel Prize in 2001, and Shiller, a Yale professor who in time should do likewise, are both outstanding economists, and the work they review in each of these areas of research is of high quality. In this respect, their book is similar to recent offerings by other scholars that have also presented for a broader audience many of the findings of what has come to be known as "behavioral economics."[3]

Akerlof and Shiller, however, want Animal Spirits to do more than summarize distinct findings and their separate implications for policy. They see the limitations of today's conventional macroeconomics as systemic: "the theories economists typically put forth about how the economy works are too simplistic. That means we should fire the weather forecaster." And "firing the forecaster means giving up the myth that capitalism is purely good."

In an intuitively appealing illustration, Akerlof and Shiller suggest how to think about what's included and what's not in conventional economic theory, and what they intend their book to accomplish:

Picture a square divided into four boxes, denoting motives that are economic or noneconomic and responses that are rational or irrational. The current model fills only the upper left-hand box; it answers the question: How does the economy behave if people only have economic motives, and if they respond to them rationally? But that leads immediately to three more questions, corresponding to the three blank boxes.... We believe that the answers to the most important questions regarding how the macroeconomy behaves and what we ought to do when it misbehaves lie largely (though not exclusively) within those three blank boxes.

One of the inevitable difficulties with this kind of argument is that it depends so much on just how words are used. What is the difference between an economic and a noneconomic motive? If I buy a new car because I like its styling and good gas mileage, that's presumably an economic motive. What if it's a hybrid and part of my reason for buying it is that I value the "story" of my doing my bit to help slow global warming? If a business owner provides scholarships for his employees' children, is his motive to treat them fairly for fairness' sake or to foster their loyalty and thereby improve their productivity?

The answer, in the end, is that an "economic" motive is whatever economists include in their theories of how people behave. And since different economists are always proposing different theories, what constitutes an "economic" motive can differ from one theory, and one economist, to another. Since at any particular time there are dominant theories, there is some coherence to what people would understand as an "economic" motive; and so the point Akerlof and Shiller are trying to make here is far from empty. But it is more elusive than they suggest. The distinction between what's "rational" and what's not is, if anything, even more fraught.

Sometimes, moreover, Akerlof and Shiller's substantive arguments fall victim to a similar circularity. The element of animal spirits on which they place the most emphasis in their account of the current crisis is confidence. It is, they say, "the first and most crucial of our animal spirits." Is it rational or not for me to put my money in a bank in which I have confidence? Or to buy a stock if I have confidence in the company's business prospects? According to Akerlof and Shiller, this kind of behavior is, by definition, irrational since "confidence" for them is a kind of faith, not a matter of rational analysis: "The very term confidence...impl[ies] behavior that goes beyond a rational approach to decision making." (Similarly, when confidence is explained in terms of trust, "the very meaning of trust is that we go beyond the rational.")

This tendency to argue by definition also sometimes affects questions beyond whether something is to be classified as economic or noneconomic, or rational or irrational. One of the reasons confidence is so important in Akerlof and Shiller's list of animal spirits is that when people have too much of it, they behave in ways that cause the economy to become overheated. But this argument, too, turns out to be a matter of definition: "The term overheated economy, as we shall use it, refers to a situation in which confidence has gone beyond normal bounds...."

Concerns like these aside, the broader question is whether Akerlof and Shiller succeed in making more of the different kinds of research they report on in Animal Spirits than the sum of the book's disparate parts. The answer is yes in some respects, no in others.

They succeed in demonstrating both the narrowness of mainstream macroeconomic thinking in recent decades and the stranglehold that this thinking has placed on the economics profession's ability either to explain phenomena like today's crisis or to advance potential solutions. For example, economics today is largely taught using mathematical models to describe outcomes under different conditions. And for purposes of macroeconomics—the study of the economy as a whole—most of the standard models do not admit the possibility of unemployment. The reason is not that no one knows unemployment exists. Rather, no one has figured out how to allow for it within the confines of sufficiently simple mathematics; and faced with the choice between excluding unemployment and sacrificing analytical simplicity, most macroeconomists have opted for the former.

To point to another example even more central to what is happening currently, the standard macroeconomic analysis today also does not acknowledge the existence of banking or other kinds of borrowing and lending. Instructive models of credit markets are certainly available.[4] But incorporating them within the standard macroeconomic models would place too much strain on mathematical simplicity.

Akerlof and Shiller succeed, too, in demonstrating that conventional macroeconomic analyses often fail because they omit not just readily observable facts like unemployment and institutions such as credit markets but also harder-to-document behavioral patterns that fall within the authors' notion of "animal spirits." Confidence plainly matters, and so does the absence of it. When the public mood swings from exuberance to anxiety, or even fear, the effect on asset prices as well as on economic activity outside the financial sector can be large.

As they argue, these effects can plausibly be larger than the fluctuations attributable to more concrete factors, such as monetary policy or oil prices, that economists more typically incorporate in their analysis. Money illusion, by which people are influenced by purely nominal price movements, is also clearly important to some aspects of how the economy in aggregate behaves. (As they show, concerns for fairness, tendencies toward corruption, and reliance on "stories" also influence some aspects of economic behavior, but whether they are significant for the aggregate economy remains unclear.) "It is necessary," they argue,

to incorporate animal spirits into macroeconomic theory in order to know how the economy really works. In this respect the macroeconomics of the past thirty years has gone in the wrong direction.

The effort to "clean up macroeconomics and make it more scientific," to impose "research structure and discipline," has proved disastrously confining.

But what then? Is there more to Animal Spirits than a list of important influences for economists to try to take into account? Akerlof and Shiller believe they have proposed a new model for macroeconomic analysis. Comparing their work to Keynes's discussion of animal spirits from the 1930s, they write:

This book...describes how the economy really works.... With the advantage of over seventy years of research in the social sciences, we can develop the role of animal spirits in macroeconomics in a way that the early Keynesians could not. And because we acknowledge the importance of animal spirits, and accord them a central place in our theory rather than sweep them under the rug, this theory is not vulnerable to attack.

There are two problems here. One is simply the familiar tendency to overstate, especially when writing about one's own work. It is hard to believe that Akerlof and Shiller really see their ideas as invulnerable to attack. Similarly, after listing at the outset the subjects about which they will summarize the research that they and other scholars have done—e.g., "Why do economies fall into depression?"—they declare that "animal spirits provide an easy answer to each of these questions." The answers they summarize may be right or not (I vote yes) and they may be well argued or not, but they are not "easy."

The more important question is whether what Akerlof and Shiller have offered in Animal Spirits amounts to "a theory" in the sense that it could stand in place of the current theories that they criticize for being based entirely on rational responses to economic motives. There is a difference between a series of ideas about different aspects of economic behavior and an integrated account of macroeconomic fluctuations. Akerlof and Shiller are surely on the right track in pointing to elements that are missing from today's conventional models, and in arguing that incorporating them into mainstream macroeconomic analysis would help. But they have neither done this nor shown others how to. Hence their goal of replacing what macroeconomists teach their students is likely to be disappointed, at least for now.

And because what they have here is a set of examples of how "animal spirits" matter for specific aspects of economic behavior, not a coherently worked out theory of how the macroeconomy behaves, it is not surprising that Animal Spirits is also thin on suggestions for what to do about the current crisis. Akerlof and Shiller mostly restrict their recommendations to how economists should think, not what policymakers should do. The one concrete proposal they offer is that the government should have a target for the expansion of credit—that is, for the amount of borrowing and lending in the economy, presumably defined in some measurable way.

This idea has considerable merit (some years ago I wrote a series of papers advocating it myself[5]). But it is hard to see how it would help address the problems our economy faces today. Everyone knows that a principal objective of the Treasury's bank bailouts, the Federal Reserve's numerous new facilities for credit, the government's takeover of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, as well as other actions, is to restore the functioning of the credit markets so that borrowers can again obtain financing. It is not clear how stating a specific target for credit expansion would help further that goal. It is also not clear that the proposal follows, in any direct way, from the importance of animal spirits in influencing economic behavior.

What else? The "world of animal spirits gives the government an opportunity to step in," Akerlof and Shiller write. But in what ways? Apart from a target for credit growth, they mostly leave it at that. "This book cannot give the detailed answers" to current policy questions, they write. This is a pity. Because they are so convincing in their critique of modern macroeconomics, and because they point to the current crisis as a prime example of why this matters, readers will understandably want to know what policies they would recommend.

In his recent book The Subprime Solution, Shiller offered a series of proposals, recommending, for example, a new version of the Home Owners' Loan Corporation. which operated from 1933 to 1936 and provided generous subsidies for home mortgages, insisting, however, that they be paid off by steady monthly payments. He also advocated expanded financial disclosure requirements, greater availability of financial data, and a new government agency like the Consumer Product Safety Commission that could protect consumers by informing them about the safety of financial products.

Shiller made more far-reaching suggestions as well, proposing markets in which families could insure the risk inherent in owning their house[6] or earning their livelihood, and even a new way of expressing prices in a unit of account that would adjust for inflation or deflation, so as to help people overcome money illusion. Here he anticipated the discussion of "animal spirits" in his book with Akerlof:

The subprime crisis was essentially psychological in origin.... Denying the importance of psychology and other social sciences for financial theory would be analogous to physicists denying the importance of friction in the application of Newtonian mechanics.

But The Subprime Solution was (by intent) mostly focused on mortgages and the fallout from the subprime collapse. In Animal Spirits, Akerlof and Shiller make a much broader argument, but they say little about its concrete implications for macroeconomic policies: How much and what kind of fiscal stimulus is desirable now? What should be the role for monetary policy now that short-term interest rates are near zero? What changes should be made in financial regulation once the crisis is past?

Some of the proposals for regulatory reform now being put forward by others appear at least to connect to parts of Akerlof and Shiller's discussion. For example, they call attention to the potential instability inherent in the "new shadow banking system"—that is, institutions such as investment banks and even the off-balance-sheet entities sponsored by the banks themselves that now carry out many of the lending functions of banks but are not regulated as such and whose obligations are not ordinarily insured. They observe, correctly, that "there can be a 'run' on these institutions just as there can be a run on traditional banks." They are right; what happened last year to Bear Stearns and Lehman was, in effect, a run on a nonbank.

But what, then, should be done to prevent more such runs? Some ideas now under discussion include stronger accounting rules and wider capital requirements, so that hedge funds and insurance companies and other nonbanks too would have to hold capital against their risk positions. There is also support for empowering the government to take "prompt corrective action" to force nonbanks to address problems in their balance sheets, or if necessary take them into receivership, just as it already can with banks. A more controversial idea is to reinstitute some form of the Glass-Steagall Act that, until Congress repealed it in 1999, barred commercial banks from also doing investment banking. The Obama administration has proposed a new financial "super-regulator." How do animal spirits bear specifically on any of these issues? Akerlof and Shiller do not say.

But their silence on these and other policy issues and their lack of a full-blown "theory" to replace the strait-jacketed macroeconomics of the past few decades do not undercut the force of Akerlof and Shiller's central argument. Their harsh judgment of current mainstream macroeconomic thinking is true, and they are right about the importance of what they call "animal spirits" to many of its crippling shortcomings. Animal Spirits provides an agenda for new thinking, and one well worth pursuing.

—April 30, 2009
Notes

[1]Data are from the US Department of Commerce. "Finance" here excludes both insurance and real estate; with those additional firms included, the share of total profits in 2001–2005 was 37 percent.

[2]Thomas Philippon and Ariell Reshef, "Skill Biased Financial Development: Education, Wages and Occupations in the US Financial Sector," National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 13437, September 2007.

[3]See, for example, Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein, Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth and Happiness (Yale University Press, 2008), reviewed in these pages by John Cassidy, June 12, 2008.

[4]Interestingly, many of Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke's most important contributions as an academic economist were models for analyzing the role of credit markets, including ways in which a falling value of either lenders' capital or borrowers' collateral can depress lending and therefore economic activity. See, for example, Bernanke and Alan S. Blinder, "Money, Credit and Aggregate Demand," The American Economic Review, May 1988; and Bernanke and Mark Gertler, "Agency Costs, Net Worth and Business Fluctuations," The American Economic Review, March 1989.

[5]See, for example, "Monetary Policy with a Credit Aggregate Target," Journal of Monetary Economics, Spring 1983 Supplement.

[6]The market for futures based on either nationwide or city-specific house price indexes, which Shiller helped to establish on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, is a practical step in that direction.
By Benjamin M. Friedman

Thursday, August 27, 2009

It’s Hard to Worry About a Deficit 10 Years Out

Ten years ago, Washington was worried about the budget outlook, and there were forecasts of dire outcomes. And so it is today.

The difference is the nature of the worries. Alan Greenspan, then the Federal Reserve chairman, talked about the dangers of a shortage of Treasury securities as the $5 trillion surplus forecast for the next decade enabled the national debt to be paid down. This week we were warned of a $9 trillion deficit over the next 10 years.

“The last time people got really excited about a 10-year budget outlook, they were hysterically wrong about what transpired,” said Robert Barbera, the chief economist of ITG, who mocked the surplus forecasts then and now thinks the consensus outlook is too negative.

“The $5 trillion surplus was a ‘nothing can go wrong’ forecast,” he said. “No recessions, no wars, no bear markets and a perpetuation of inexplicably high tax receipts. You can make the case that the current conversations about our fiscal outlook are effectively, ‘Nothing can go right.’ The estimates assume we continue to allocate over $100 billion a year for fighting wars. They assume a very mild recovery for the economy, and an even milder recovery for tax receipts.”

It was easier a decade ago to know the forecast was foolish, although few did. The assumption that politicians would refrain from cutting taxes or raising spending in the face of large surpluses had no historical support.

On the other hand, the notion that politicians will point fingers and do nothing as deficits mount has plenty of historical support.

One unusual factor now is that everyone agrees Congress must pass a new tax law. If it does not, taxes on nearly everyone will soar under an absurd plan enacted in 2001 called the snap-back tax, which provides that in 2011 the tax law that had been in effect in 2000 will reappear.

That would drive tax rates up sharply for most people, which might reduce budget deficits. But it is hardly what anyone wants if the economy is not booming by then.

Most of the tax changes being mulled can await Congressional action until next year. Under the snap-back tax plan, however, the estate tax is set to vanish for a year if nothing happens before the end of 2009, just over four months from now.

Heirs of a very rich person who died on Dec. 31, 2010, would get everything, without any estate tax. If that person died a day later, his or her estate would owe 55 percent of everything over $1 million. (I call that the Dr. Kevorkian provision, after the physician who specialized in assisted suicides until he was sent to prison.) How will hospitals respond if heirs demand that life support be ended before the clock strikes 12?

It would have been nice to fix that up in a nonelection year, but the health care debate has consumed Congress. The chairman of one tax-writing committee, Senator Max Baucus, is still trying to shape a bipartisan health care bill, a Sisyphean task that may not leave much time for taxes. The other chairman, Representative Charles Rangel, has just discovered that he forgot to mention a checking account with more than $250,000 in it when he listed his assets. Tax policy may not be on the top of his to-do list either, at least while the dual investigations of his ethics are continuing.

The country got into the current tax mess because George W. Bush wanted it all in 2001. He could overcome procedural hurdles in the Senate and make the 10-year cost of his tax cut appear lower, if the entire bill was labeled temporary. So it was.

To make things worse, that bill did nothing about the alternative minimum tax, which was supposed to catch wealthy citizens with big deductions and force them to pay something. By not lowering the A.M.T. rates when ordinary tax rates were cut, the law negated the cuts for millions of middle-class people. Now Congress passes a temporary fix every year to keep that from happening. President Obama wants to make that fix permanent, something Mr. Bush was hesitant to do because it would have made deficit forecasts look worse.

When Congress does get around to tax law, the political calculations could be fun to watch. Read the numbers one way, and President Obama’s proposals call for big increases in taxes on every group. Read them another way, they call for tax cuts for every group except the most prosperous one-tenth of 1 percent of Americans. Guess which interpretation the Republicans, and the Democrats, will choose.

The numbers to back each interpretation come from a new study by the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, estimating effective federal tax rates using both current law and President Obama’s legislative proposals. The figures include all federal taxes, allocating corporate taxes to the owners of those companies and payroll taxes to the employees. Middle-income people tend to pay higher payroll taxes than the rich, because there is no Social Security tax on high incomes. The poorest are exempt from income tax, but do pay payroll taxes if they earn money.

In 2009, the average effective rate for all Americans is estimated to be 18.2 percent. The center estimates that if there are no changes in the law, that will rise to 23.4 percent in 2012. If the president’s proposals are all adopted, the figure that year will be 20.7 percent, with increases from 2009 for every group — those with the lowest incomes as well as those with the highest. How can that be, given that the president has promised to raise taxes only on those who make at least $250,000 a year?

Roberton Williams, a senior fellow at the Tax Policy Center, points to two reasons. First, Mr. Obama does not want to continue some special tax breaks, like a tax credit for new homeowners, that were part of the stimulus package he pushed through Congress. More important, the 2012 estimates assume a better economy, in which incomes will be higher and more people will therefore be in higher tax brackets.
By FLOYD NORRIS